Current Moon Phase

Full Moon
100% of full

Farmers Almanac
The 2014 Farmers Almanac
Farmers' Almanac

Why Butter’s Better

Why Butter’s Better

For many years, a major rift has divided this country. I’m not talking about urban versus rural, or even Democrat versus Republican. The split I’m talking about is the ongoing clash between butter and margarine.

Growing up, I’m not sure I was very aware of the difference. My mother bought and used margarine almost exclusively — a residual, most likely, of her lean 1940s upbringing. It didn’t matter much to me; I was used to it, and we all just called it “butter,” anyway.

Over the years, though, I began to notice the butter served at my grandmother’s house on holidays was a lot tastier than the stuff mom spread on my morning toast. Eventually, I came to understand the difference, and began to look forward to my rare encounters with real butter.

Though mom still uses margarine in her kitchen, I’ve been a committed butter convert for years, and have never looked back. Call me extravagant or reckless, but at my house there is just no substitute for the real thing, and for plenty of reasons.

A Question of Taste
I know, I know; flavor is just a matter of opinion. What tastes good to one person won’t necessarily appeal to someone else. Still, if you ask any of the millions of margarine enthusiasts out there why they eschew butter, chances are they’ll talk about the purported health benefits or the lower price.

Though there is no scientific data out there to prove it — short of a few “blind taste tests” undertaken over the years by a number of cooking magazines — most people agree that butter tastes better. Even when a particular brand of margarine wins praise for its flavor, the compliment usually rests on the merit of its resemblance to butter. Real butter is the standard by which we judge other spreads.

Regardless of how many millions of dollars the major margarine manufacturers spend to convince buying public otherwise, there’s just something about the creamy, rich flavor of butter that the imitators have never been able to successfully replicate.

The Skinny on Fats
Like anything else that tastes good, butter has a bad reputation. People assume anything we enjoy must somehow be bad for us. With butter, that assumption has been strengthened by the margarine industry, which, for years, has claimed to be healthier for the heart and better for the waistline.

Those claims are just not true. Both butter and margarine contain about the same amount of calories and overall fat. The attacks leveled at butter are based on its higher content of saturated fat — fat from animal sources linked by the American Heart Association to a higher risk of heart disease.

But a 1994 Harvard University study showed that hydrogenated oils, which are contained in many brands of margarine, nearly double the risk of heart attack. Several other major studies have also indicated a strong correlation between earlier death and consumption of high amounts of trans-fat, the kind of fat contained in most brands of margarine.

It’s only fair to point out that most margarine manufacturers have been working since the mid-90s to reduce the amount of trans-fats in their products. For those on special diets that strictly limit fat intake, low-fat spreads probably remain the best choice. Just beware of deceptive labeling. Even products legally labeled as containing “zero grams” of trans-fat may still contain up to 500 mg per serving

Light margarines and spreads are not hydrogenated, so they are soft and usually sold in tubs rather than sticks. The major problem with such light spreads is their unsuitability for cooking and baking. Because they contain only about 25% fat, they won’t work in most recipes.

Back to Nature
During the latter part of the last century, the natural foods movement was seen by the mainstream as a little bit wacky. More recently, however, people are beginning to embrace the wisdom of returning to the way our great-grandparents once ate.

Like fresh fruits and vegetables or whole grains, butter is a natural, wholesome food. It contains nutrients our bodies need for energy production and other vital processes. Mary Enig, a certified nutritional specialist and researcher in the field of lipid biochemistry, has credited butter consumption with such benefits as a stronger immune system, less vulnerability to arthritis and osteoporosis, gastrointestinal health, and normal thyroid function.

Most of the nutrients in margarine are added in during production. And though organic variants of both butter and margarine are available, margarine generally contains a higher proportion of chemical additives than butter.

Paying the Price
In at least one area, butter lovers must concede a victory to margarine. Butter usually sells for more than twice the price of margarine. Despite all of the rhetoric about margarine being healthier, cost has been its major selling point ever since it was first invented in 1869 as a low-cost butter alternative for the French government to feed to enlisted men.

For those who insist they just can’t afford to put out the extra money for real butter, there can be no real argument. We must all decide how best to live within our means, and most of us learn to do without things other people consider necessities.

For most people, though, the price difference amounts to less than a few dollars each month. Anyone who prefers butter, but continues to buy margarine because it’s cheaper, ought to reexamine the situation. By keeping your intake of fatty spreads to a minimum — something we should all do for our health anyway — the difference becomes negligible. Most of us splurge a little every week on luxuries like coffee or snack foods, so why not treat yourself and your family to the superior flavor, cooking versatility and nutritional benefits of natural butter?

24 comments

1 angela { 08.23.12 at 1:29 am }

Oh my goodness, never had so much fun reading about butter, too much margarine in my life lately, and my newly acquired awesome homemade bread recipe deserves the real deal. Lol, glad to have read, thx!

2 heavy hedonist { 01.13.12 at 3:39 pm }

Nice article, Jaime. I, too, love the taste, versatility and superior quality of natural butter, especially locally made and organic. If you use unsalted, you cut out the excess sodium as well, and within a week, believe me, you won’t miss it. It’s unmatched for flavor and texture in baking, unlike water-filled margarine.

When I want to wow guests at dinner, I serve my own fresh baked bread and homemade butter… easy to make and it never fails to please.

Peace, Mari

3 Diane Pilon { 01.08.12 at 10:57 am }

I agree with all of the above butter is definetly BETTER, HEALTHER,AND OH SOOO GOOD
were being fed enough poisons as it is Im sticking to BUTTER….

4 Pam { 01.07.12 at 4:34 pm }

Yes that hydro oil turns to plastic on the outside of your coffeemate container. So when I saw that wow, now I use half and half or darigold outs out a good creamer and baileys is not too bad. I have always used butter spareingly if not peanut butter the store kind as the others have the oil too. Cool whip is another,,,use the can instead. I drink apple cider vinegar with lemon in water, this will help keep system clean along with aloe versa juice. Keep well

5 Butch { 01.07.12 at 1:30 pm }

I miss the days of churning real butter while watching our 1st tv. Also spreading fresh butter on Mom’s, fresh homemade bread. We grew up on fresh cow’s milk and fresh butter, my Dad turns 90 this month. Must be from all that fresh milk, eggs and butter we use.

6 Jayla SunBird { 01.07.12 at 1:25 pm }

BUTT-TERRRR! IS: BET-TERRRR!

7 CB { 01.06.12 at 3:36 pm }

Trying to use “imitation” magarine (spreads) to cook with is futile. I’ve gone back to butter and find I’m less generous with it because of the cost. Being less generous with it is definately saving me some calories. I’m enjoying the change.

8 Ali { 01.05.12 at 10:51 pm }

I agree…butter is the real food…I use it for cooking, and from time to time I use virgin coconut oil to spread on my toast and a dollop in my coffee (with cream and honey) :)

9 Merry Winter { 01.05.12 at 2:05 pm }

Butter is better but do we need to be concerned about the milk it is made from coming from cows fed on drugs and altered grain and corn ? Nothing is as it seems anymore and eating in general has become rather scary..Wondering where it will all end if we dont smarten up.

10 Tracy { 01.05.12 at 11:24 am }

I agree butter is better. We need to eat more like our grandparents.

11 Dawn { 01.05.12 at 10:51 am }

It is simple for me, margarine is chemically stuffed artificial ‘food’ and butter is real. Eat foods with the fewest ingredients and the closest to nature you can find.

12 Shaari :) { 01.04.12 at 7:35 pm }

Actually,
Cold pressed virgin olive oil is far better than butter and works great in recipes. There’s no casein, no lactase, and if you want to cut back on fat calories substitute apple sauce for half the fat called for in a recipe.

13 Pam { 01.04.12 at 6:03 pm }

One word: POPCORN! Try melting some margarine for your popcorn and watch it wilt and go limp as you pour it on. Besides — as we seem to mostly agree — lobster with melted margarine — where is the fun in THAT???

14 Jack { 01.04.12 at 3:05 pm }

For Del et al: Margarine does contain some of the same ingredients as plastic – petroleum distilates. “Butter Is Better”!

15 steven { 01.04.12 at 3:01 pm }

man-made chemicals added to all our foods I believe is making us obese and a sick nation.
I switched back to butter and plan to stay with it.

16 araucano { 01.04.12 at 12:12 pm }

Hi:
enjoy your margarine!!!!! I risk my life on behalf of taste,and I know that in many countries in the world still consume a lot of butter…….I do not wish to live for ever….
I’m planning to leave with a full belly……;)

17 dudley wong { 01.04.12 at 11:01 am }

I use Becel margarine as a spread on toast or bread, but use butter mixed with extra virgin olive oil for sauteing, as it won’t burn. Must use a dab of real butter for frying eggs; it’s de rigeur I am a retired chef and over the years, I have never heard of a cook or baker that espouses margarine over butter!!

18 Joyce G { 01.04.12 at 10:42 am }

I bake/cook with butter. I don’t put spreads on bread, so don’t use margarine there. However, I do use one particular brand of margarine for toast some of the time.

19 Jean Middleton { 01.04.12 at 10:02 am }

I Heard YEARS AGO THE SIDE EFFECTS OF MARGARINE. I FOUND OUT MY PUMPKIN ROLLS TASTE AND DO A LOT BETTER WITH REAL BUTTER, NO MORE MARGARINE FOR ME.

20 Terry { 01.04.12 at 9:40 am }

Agree!!! Butter :)

21 MeMaw { 01.04.12 at 9:25 am }

Butter is Better. When I was a child margarine was white like lard,came in a plastic bag with an orange color button type in the middle of it. You squeezed the button to color the margarine yellow. Later years I read that Margarine was made during the war to feed the hogs. Don’t know if that statement is true or not, But, needless to say, I ONLY BUY REAL BUTTER!

22 Del { 01.04.12 at 9:09 am }

I’ve always been told that margarine is a synthetic plastic so yep, I stick with butter but use the Brummel & Brown made from yogurt for daily consumption, but when baking, you gotta have the real thing. YUM!

23 Joe { 01.04.12 at 9:00 am }

Can’t beat good butter filling those knooks and crannies on a toasted englih muffin

24 Jayne { 01.03.12 at 4:32 pm }

Butter makes it better! ;)

Leave a Comment

Note: Comments that further the discussion of the above content are likely to be approved. Those comments that are vague or are simply submitted in order to promote a product, service or web site, although not necessarily considered "spam," are generally not approved.

If you notice a hole in the upper left-hand corner of your Farmers' Almanac, don't return it to the store! That hole isn't a defect; it's a part of history. Starting with the first edition of the Farmers' Almanac in 1818, readers used to nail holes into the corners to hang it up in their homes, barns, and outhouses (to provide both reading material and toilet paper). In 1910, the Almanac's publishers began pre-drilling holes in the corners to make it even easier for readers to keep all of that invaluable information (and paper) handy.